Sen. Richard Durbin (news, bio, voting record), D-Ill., pressed Rumsfeld on whether there will be one uniform standard for interrogations, which he said was the intent of McCain's legislation. And he asked whether the manual would allow anything that "would be considered unlawful if it were employed against American service members?"
Rumsfeld ducked the question as he normally does:
Rumsfeld did not say whether there would be one uniform standard.
But he said the manual, which will guide troops on the handling of detainees, "will comply with U.S. law."
I don't think John McCain really believed him... McCain's reply:
Told of that remark, McCain said: "Good. Glad to hear that. That means that we've had a successful discussion."
But guess what? They want to keep those parts of the manual dealing with prisoner interrogation secret. Can you guess why?
Defense officials had also been debating whether to keep certain specific interrogation techniques secret, by including them in a classified section of the manual. Several members of Congress privately cautioned the Pentagon that keeping parts secret could raise suspicions that the United States was violating international and U.S. laws.